Why Your Practice Swing and Real Swing Aren't the Same

Sorry, you need to be a member to access this video.
You Are Just Seconds Away - Become a member here!
Already a member? Log in now

Why are my practice swings so different from my real swings? This age old question has eluded an answer - until now! Learn why your practice swing isn't the same and how to fix it!


How many of you guys can relate to this?

Warming up, setting up next to the ball, make a couple practice swings.

Oh yeah, felt good.

Look good.

I hope everybody's watching.

Look how pretty my golf swing is.

It's pretty tidy.

Oh yeah, I'm ready.

Okay, let's do this.

If you can relate to that guy, perfect practice swings, awful real swing, when the ball's there, listen up because I'm going to explain to you once and for all why that happens.

It's very, very simple, but the fix is a long-term fix.

As you know, I don't do band-aid fixes.

The whole reason that you have a beautiful practice swing and an awful real golf swing when the ball's there is because you're not prioritizing the right things in your swing.

For instance, What happens nine times out of 10 when people are doing drills and they're in front of a mirror and they're working on everything, they're just focusing on their movements, right?

I'm focusing on what I feel here and so on and so forth, all the stuff you've heard me talk about.

But when I put the ball down, all of that stuff goes out the window and all of a sudden, all I care about is hitting that stupid ball with the stick.

That's not where your focus should be when you're working on something in your golf swing.

Your focus has to be the same thing that you were focusing on when you were looking in the mirror.

If you're focusing on feeling right shoulder blade, right glute, when the ball's there, that doesn't change.

You're still thinking right shoulder blade, right glute.

I tell my students all the time, I'd rather you chunk it or skull it or shank it or miss it completely and do the movement correctly, then worry about what that stupid little white devil's telling you to do.

The ball is irrelevant when you're teaching yourself a new movement pattern.

What matters is what you're focusing on.

It's getting you in the right positions that will eventually make everything fall into place and make hitting the ball very, very easy.

That's problem number one.

Problem number two is power sources.

When you're making a practice swing, typically, let's say that you swing at 100 miles an hour.

Well, your practice swing might only be about 60 miles an hour.

So it's way slower.

And so you can make these nice, calm, smooth practice swings because you know there's no ball there.

So you're not worried about the ball and you're not worried about putting any speed into it.

However, when you know that you've got to hit this hard ball with this hard club, you want to put some oomph into it.

Your power sources, if they're not in the right place, will cause you to make a horrible, Horrible downswing, because all of a sudden you're going to take over with what you think is going to produce power in the swing, which is typically going to be your arms, hands, and shoulders.

You know by now that it's weight shift and your trunk rotating that brings the club halfway down.

It's doing all of the heavy lifting to get the downswing started.

But if you go to the top and you don't feel this loaded up, and you feel your arms and shoulders loaded up, well you're going to go right back to your old habits of where you are used to getting power.

The hardest trick with learning rotary swing is understanding that it's not going to feel like you're doing very much work.

When you get over that hang up that you don't have to do so much, and you get over this little mind trick, all of a sudden the golf swing becomes much easier.

You can hit the ball with what you quote call your practice swing.

Because your power is coming from big muscles that don't really have to work that hard to produce proper club edge speed.

But if you're just relying on your arms and hands, you're always going to cast the club, which is going to cause you to lose all of your leverage.

And you're going to start scooping and flipping out and doing all kinds of other crazy things because your power sources are in the wrong place.

So the two main issues when your practice swing and your real swing aren't the same is A, you're changing your focus.

You're focusing on the ball and not your movements.

That got you in the right positions when you were looking in the mirror.

You've got to keep your focus on the movements, what your body is doing.

The club and ball will take care of itself as you learn to move your body correctly.

And And then problem number two, or B, is that you're providing power from the wrong place in your real swing.

You try to hit too hard, you try to do it with your arms and hands and shoulders, and there's not enough power, There's not enough muscle mass there to generate the horsepower required to swing the club with any speed.

So you have to focus on trusting your big muscles to help you bring the club down with lag.

As you have lag, you've got leverage and leverage is a multiplier.

So all of a sudden, I don't have to swing so hard when my hands are here.

All I got to do is let this leverage unfold, just like swinging a hammer.

And this is a lot of speed available to me with no effort.

But if I'm throwing the club from the top and I have no leverage, as I get down here, I have to use my body to try and help it out.

The whole trick is working through the RST five-step stuff in sequence.

I know weight shift isn't that exciting.

I get it.

I'm going to make you eat your veggies first.

You've got to learn the core fundamental movements of the golf swing that all tour pros do.

Weight shift and core rotation are the engine of your swing, not your hands, arms, and shoulders.

Those are byproducts.

Let your body move those.

You'll have more levers than you know what to do with.

And all of a sudden, you won't be that guy wailing around at the ball, even though you have a perfect looking practice swing.

Must be Premium Member to Comment

64x64
Robert
On the backswing do you stop the backswing as soon as the buttons on the shirt stop moving?
March 16, 2019
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Robert. The backswing is completed when you have a full shoulder turn. If the arms start to swing freely on their own. You will notice the buttons stop moving, but that doesn't mean you have completed a proper turn.
March 17, 2019
64x64
Chris
So after all my reps, watching video, I went out to play and did quite poorly on the front 9 but improved on back 9- I’m sure this has happened before was is rs advice for this situation?
February 9, 2019
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Chris. It's quite common that you were probably stuck between old and new movement patterns. The best way to figure this out is to have someone film the on course movement, so you know what items you need to hit home with the most.
February 9, 2019
64x64
Chris
The million dollar question after watching and repping all rst videos etc I’m now playing my first round in a few days - so how do we take this to the course?
February 6, 2019
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Chris. Correct reps and you can do it perfectly without thought? That's the first thing to check. Secondly, the goal when first going to the course isn't score and ball striking. It's making the proper move. It will take time for your brain to automatically choose the new movement pattern. It will want to revert back to what it is comfortable with. Pick at least one item you struggled with, or really had to focus hard on when making the swing change. Your goal should be to make that move come hell or high water anytime you make the swing. This way your brain can start to process this is what you are trying to accomplish. Forget about the ball as much as possible and focus on correct movements.
February 6, 2019
64x64
Drew
Hello, I have this same issue. My practice swing feels and looks great, but in my real swing I do all sorts of different things. My question relates to "eating my veggies first" Is there a balance between doing a lot of practice swings vs hitting golf balls that will help make this transition easier? Or put another way, if I would just focus on practice swings for a couple of months to really ingrain it at all speeds before going to the range and hitting balls, would this lead to better results? Is there an optimal balance between practice swings and hitting balls? Thanks!
January 21, 2019
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Drew. Ideally, you would spend enough time with practice swings and increasing the pace to where the mechanics/swing is correct without thinking about it. Then, gradually add the ball back. Figure out where you falter and hone in more time with those specific issues. You need to challenge yourself along the way to see how progress is coming. But, in the initial it's about ironing out reps, proper motion and feel.
January 21, 2019
64x64
Blake
For me, real vs. practice is also because my brain fights the idea that I can hit the ball with my hands ahead of the ball. It wants me to line up the club, my hands and the ball in a vertical line where very early on I can see the clubface descending into the ball. Am I alone? Also - even when I release from trail thigh, my club seems to catch up to my hands too quickly. Does this mean I haven’t turned my knuckles down to the ground enough?
December 18, 2018
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Blake. You are in the minority of what your brain wants to see at impact, but not uncommon. If the club is catching up too quickly you released early by thumb push, or over active trail hand.
December 18, 2018
64x64
Christopher
“I’m gonna make you eat you’re veggies first”! Pure Gold! - Love it Chuck. Keep telling us what we need to hear!! Are you coming to the UK to do a clinic? Keep on swinging! Chris
October 25, 2018
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Chris. Right now we don't have any scheduled in the UK. But, you never know. Always a possibility with the amount of requests we get. Glad you liked the video.
October 25, 2018
64x64
Alex
Rotaryswing roadshow to Las Vegas, please!
October 25, 2018
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Alex. Roadshow is up to our members. Fill out the information on the link below to make it happen. https://rotaryswing.com/free-golf-lessons
October 25, 2018
64x64
Jeffrey
This concept really makes me understand the dynamics and sequencing of the golf swing. As I've gotten older in spite of a small fortune in lessons, golf videos and endless practice my game has not improved. This has really impressed and invigorated me.
October 24, 2018
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Jeffrey. Awesome. Thanks for the post.
October 24, 2018
64x64
Peter
Great video. Your point about trusting the big muscles is absolutely essential. I have noticed that delaying the shoulders, arms and wrists produces better distance and consistency. Too much effort too soon seems to me to be the hallmark of the high handicapper( speaking as one ).
October 24, 2018
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Peter. Very true. Firing from the wrong place at the wrong time and with lots of effort is essentially the high handicappers downfall.
October 24, 2018
64x64
Chris (Certified RST Instructor)
Hey guys, I've been through the 5 step process at least twice, including doing 3000-5000 reps on each movement and I even started stacking movements to be more fluid. With that being said I still have a major flaw of what everyone calls a "looptie loop" at the top of my backswibac. I play about 1 to 2 rounds per week and am concluding that maybe I should go 3 or 4 months without taking any full swings until I've not only mastered the moves (which I can do in my sleep at half speed) but have trained my body to forget the flaws that seem to keep appearing every time I play. After 3 years of working on this, should I try that or is there another way that I can't seem to find? Maybe play a round but commit to only swinging half speed? Thanks for the input as I'm 100% in on RST benefits
October 24, 2018
64x64
Craig (Certified RST Instructor)
Hello Chris. Exactly. If you can perform the moves properly in a practice swing (no loopy change, maintaining tilt, etc..). And, can with a decent amount of pace. Not full rip, but moderate. Then, you need to challenge yourself to make that change outside. Next time you go to the range figure out what pace you can make the swing at being done properly. It may be a very slow one to start, but gauge where you are. Repeat, and gradually build up until you can at a moderate pace. Then, challenge yourself on the course with a box of pinnacles to make the move on the golf course without any care as to the ball flight until you can convert the swing.
October 24, 2018
64x64
James
Great video Chuck. Now all I got to do is get my wife to think about this concept and she is going to have a great golf swing because she already has great tempo but currently does too much with her arms and hands, especially at the point the direction of swing changes, i.e. at the top she starts her downswing with her hands and arms and not with her lead hip.
October 24, 2018
64x64
Chuck
Thanks James. It's extremely common. Get her working on leading the downswing with her weight shift and she'll learn she can relax her arms and hands.
October 24, 2018

We're after one thing: Real Results - Real Fast. And that's exactly what our members achieve. And that's why they say the AXIOM is: Mind-blowing. Game changing. Revolutionary.

Check it out ...

Here at RotarySwing, talk is cheap and the proof is always in the pudding. Come see the massive transformations we can achieve together in your swing.

See for yourself ...

From beginner to pro, we have what you need to get you where you want to go.

See how inside ...

RotarySwing was founded out of frustration with the current state of golf instruction. Quinton knew a better way had to exist to learn this game we all love.

Learn more ...